8 Comments
User's avatar
Ken Haycock's avatar

There are a few caveats here, none of which question your premise, however. [a] Higher salaries do not mean higher outcomes in the short term, but they do mean that better-qualified candidates are recruited to the profession. [b] A collective agreement ipso facto means that the employer agreed to the process (unfortunate, but not everything can be laid at the union's doorstep). [c] Teaching is more subjective than it needs to be; more rigorous evidence-based elements of effective instruction need to be incorporated. [d] Principals are notoriously ill-prepred to supervise and assess instruction. [e] Judges are rightly suspect of subjectivity and inadequate definitions of "satisfactory" performance.

David Clinton's avatar

Excellent points. Although if higher salaries really do lead to higher qualified teachers, we would expect to see that reflected in improved outcomes. As I wrote a few years ago (https://www.theaudit.ca/p/does-increased-public-school-funding), when correlating spending with outcomes in U.S. States - and doing something similar for Canadian provinces (https://www.theaudit.ca/p/ranking-public-education-efficiency) there's no easily-discernible impact from higher spending.

Ken Haycock's avatar

Agreed. I meant that giving current teachers will not lead to higher outcomes. I was referring to the longer term. Increased spending does not necessarily lead to higher outcomes, but there are many, many variables (countries doing better, e.g., typically have more homogeneous student populations and "more obedient" students). I also once conducted a study showing that of similarly funded public schools in one province, those that assigned more funds to school libraries had better outcomes but, again, there were contributing factors such as collaboration with classroom teachers on inquiry-based learning and promotion of voluntary reading. As I said, I think we agree. More study is needed, not just more money.

David Clinton's avatar

What metrics did you use for outcomes in your library study? I find that's the biggest problem with this kind if research: there's no perfect proxy for student success.

Ken Haycock's avatar

In order to try to be "objective," questionnaires were sent to the top and bottom-ranked elementary and secondary schools based on educational attainment from the BC Ministry of Education Foundation Skills Assessment (FSA) scores, which were translated into rankings by the Fraser Institute, a nonprofit independent, international research and educational organization.

John Chittick's avatar

Private sector unionization is in decline because in the market there is competition and having worked in large unionized corporations in competition with others, the large union shops were the first to go under. Industry employment loss can be correlated over time to strikes followed by large multi-year settlements. Not so for the public sector. While unions fight to protect all employees from dismissal, in principle, where public sector unions are involved those teachers (and nurses, professors, etc.) with opinions differing from the cultural Marxist captured "professional" governing bodies and union leaders, not so much.

There is little to no competition in schooling, making the public schools, their teachers, and unions a monopoly where the relationship with the political left is now a given. With the spectacle of blatant leftist activism in schools under nominal provincial Conservative party governance, one could easily conclude that the education complex is now a form of deep state.

PETER AIELLO's avatar

It seems that frequently teachers unions (although the more high minded above refer to them as associations in a bit of semantic mumbo jumbo) are led or controlled by activist types whose ideology may be at odds with teaching students and more in line with controlling the educational process. This can lead to the us vs them battles and thus creates divisions between the customer and the “union”.