4 Comments
User's avatar
Phil Deon's avatar

You disappoint me, David. Judging by your rationalizations, there appears to be an underlying assumption that the subjects of news reporting are equally deserving of the same number of positive and negative viewpoints regardless of their performance, and anything else is just bias.

David Clinton's avatar

That's a valid point. But it assumes the media exists to **persuade** their readers to adopt a favored position (which, in truth, has traditionally been the role for op-ed page pages rather than news pages). If, however, a media outlet claims to be neutral, then I think we should expect that their criticism should be balanced - with a decided tilt **against** whoever is the current government because, after all, they're the only ones who can be held responsible for any current public policy disasters.

And if a media outlet wants to serve a population that's largely - more or less - split down the middle politically, then any noticeable divergence from that balance suggests that they've come untethered from the public they claim to serve.

Phil Deon's avatar

Following up on the "persuasion”role… It's well known that media sources have their individual left/right biases, so one would expect to see accordingly taller or shorter bars across individual media sources. Therefore to get a good quality perspective of the overall media landscape you'd need to include all of the popular media. In that sense, the absence of Post Media from your analysis (not your fault, I understand) creates an inherent inaccuracy in the overall picture.

David Clinton's avatar

I actually think that your original observation (which I've incorporated into the post itself as an "update") hints to the possibility of weighting results to account for factors like the assumed bias of an outlet, who happens to control government, and public sentiment. There's probably more that can be squeezed out of this dataset. I'll try to get back to it some time.